Round One S72

Luke Appling Swinging

Things start getting messy here; I found out I had accidentally included Ted Simmons in the playoff in two different leagues. Coupled with the George Kelly confusion and the whole George Burns / George H. Burns fiasco, I found myself needing rather more invitees than I expected. Plus I was so close to 600 total participants, so, just like Doc Brown, I figured, “What the Hell.”

Hall-of-Famer Luke Appling is our top seed and he faces what could prove to be some tough competition. He will be battling against Joe Vosmik and 18th Century stars Ross Barnes, Fred Carroll, and Paul Hines. Just to make things interesting, he will also see stars of the 1960s and 70s Andre Thornton, Tony Conigliaro, and Thurman Munson.

The Hitters

Luke-Appling-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

From 1930 to 1950, except for a couple of years during World War II, citizens of Chicago could count on Luke Appling manning the shortstop position at Comiskey Park for the White Sox. A career .310 hitter, he won a couple of batting titles (with a .388 average in 1936) and was named to the American League All-Star team seven times. Although the war kept him from making 3000 hits, he still managed 2749 with 440 doubles and 102 triples. He was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1964.

Joe-Vosmik-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

In ten seasons as a regular (thirteen overall), Joe Vosmik managed a .307 batting average. He rapped out 1682 hits, including 335 doubles and 92 triples, leading to a very reasonable .807 OPS.

Ross-Barnes-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

Baseball pioneer Ross Barnes is considered by some to be the most dominant player of the 1870s and might just be the best hitter you have never heard of. How about these numbers: a lifetime batting average of .360! A season batting average of .400 or better four times! That was good enough for me to give him an invite to the playoff.

So why don’t we know about him? Well, Barnes only played for nine seasons, spread out over eleven years, and the first five were with the Boston Red Stockings of the National Association. Additionally, due to the short seasons, he only totaled about 2500 plate appearances and he is not in the Hall-of-Fame. He fell short of the required ten seasons but because his statistical dropoff coincided with a change in the “fair/foul” rule, the prevailing opinion was that that was the cause. Actually, he contracted a mysterious illness that sapped his strength and led to his retirement from baseball.

Fred-Carroll-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

Another early player, Fred Carroll played one season for the American Association Columbus Buckeyes and then spent the seven seasons in Pittsburgh playing for the AA Alleghenys, National League Alleghenys, Players League Burghers, and National League Pirates. He hit .284 and is in the tournament based on being in the top 150 in OPS+.

Paul-Hines-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

Paul Hines just missed qualifying for the playoff with a .302 batting average. He just missed qualifying with his 399 doubles. He just missed qualifying with his 93 triples. But his OPS+ got this baseball pioneer in. Although best known as a star of the Providence Grays, Hines got his start in 1871 as a seventeen-year-old first baseman for the National Association Washington Nationals, he eventually played for four different teams in the nation’s capital – the Blue Legs, the National League Nationals, and the American Association Statesmen.

Andre-Thornton-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

As we are now firmly in the “Players Tim Liked” phase of the playoff, it is my great pleasure to introduce Andre Thornton. A legitimate power threat, “Thunder” hit 253 home runs in his fourteen big league seasons. He carried a .254 average with enough walks to boost his OBP a hundred points higher. And he lived just down the street from my aunt and uncle!

Tony-Conigliaro-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

Tony Conigliaro fits into the “might have been” category. Playing for his hometown Boston Redsox, he showed tremendous talent, hitting a teenage record 24 home runs as a nineteen-year-old. By age 22 he had 100 homers at a younger age than anyone except Mel Ott. Alas, he liked to crowd the plate and suffered several fractures. During the 1967 pennant race, he was struck in the face by a Jack Hamilton fastball, ending his season. He missed all of 1968 but made it back to the majors in 1969. He had two more good seasons before headaches and poor vision forced him to retire. Still, he had 166 homers and an OPS of .803.

Thurman-Munson-Card Baseballs Greatest Player Playoff

An excellent defensive catcher, Thurman Munson was no slouch at the plate. A .292 hitter in his eleven-year career, Munson also hit 113 home runs. Named Rookie of the Year in 1970, he also picked up an MVP trophy in 1976 and was named to seven All-Star teams, winning three Gold Gloves along the way. His Hall-of-Fame-potential career was cut short when he was killed in a piloting accident on an off-day in 1979.

The Results

Fred Carroll8866.571*WON*
Tony Conigliaro8569.5523.0
Thurman Munson8173.5267.0
Joe Vosmik7579.48713.0
Luke Appling7579.48713.0
Andre Thornton7480.48114.0
Ross Barnes7084.45518.0
Paul Hines6886.44220.0

In a tight race – a tight season, really – Fred Carroll came out on top. The Luke Appling team led in batting average with .260 while the league hit .243 as a whole.

Season Highlights

  • Ross Barnes outscored Andre Thornton 17-2. The Barnes team had 21 hits.
  • In that game, Randy Johson gave up 10 runs in a single inning.
  • Thurman Munson defeated Andre Thornton 8-2 in a game that saw Munson outhit Thornton 25-5
  • Conigliaro99 had a 3-homer game
  • Cy Young5 of the Fred Carroll team no-hit Ross Barnes

Carroll is joined by second-place Tony Conigliaro, Thurman Munson, and Joe Vosmik and Luke Appling who tied for fourth place. The others get a second chance in Round Two.

Tim Bruno

Tim has been a baseball fan for most of his life and has played a great deal of baseball and softball over the years. Although his playing days are long behind him, he remembers back when he was an extremely fast catcher with an extremely bad arm. He has been playing Strat-o-Matic baseball since he was 14. Tim is currently living in southwest France and writes A LOT about coffee at He has also written Procaffeination: A Coffee Lover's Dictionary, which will be available soon. You can find out more about Tim's writing at and if you want to contact him about the tournament, drop him an email at

Recent Posts

link to Round 4 S26

Round 4 S26

The Hitters We are treated to a true mix of players for this elimination round, covering a broad swath of baseball history. Top seed Herman Long hails from the 19th century with...