Round One S15

Starting week three, four Hall-of-Famers vie for the top slot. Paul Molitor, Roberto Alomar, Nellie Fox, and Johnny Bench see how they measure up against Jack Doyle, Max Bishop, Mike Hargrove, and Bob Watson. The results are just ahead.

The Hitters

Image result for paul molitor

Paul Molitor had a 21-year career that saw him bat .306 and appear in 7 all-star games. His long career gave him time to amass impressive numbers, including 3,319 hits and 504 stolen bases. With a large part of two seasons lost to injuries, he might have put up some even more impressive totals.

Image result for robbie alomar

Robbie Alomar is one of the top modern second basemen. A 17-year career that saw him hit .300 and almost make the 3000 hits / 500 stolen base club. On top of that, he was a 10-time Gold Glove winner!

Image result for nellie fox
You must be good if they made a statue of you, right? That’s Nellie Fox.

Another stellar second baseman, Nellie Fox spent 19 years in the bigs, mostly with the White Sox. A solid hitter who could take a walk, he also picked up an MVP along the way.

Image result for johnny bench
If I wasn’t imagining being Roger Bresnahan, I was imagining being this guy. Alas, it was just my imagination.

When rating the catchers, for my money it has to be Johnny Bench at the top of the heap. He reinvented catcher defense and was a constant threat at the plate. In a career that blossomed during the pitching-rich 1970s, he managed to hit 389 homers and picked up a Rookie of the Year Award as well as two MVPs.

Image result for jack doyle baseball
“Dirty” Jack Doyle

I had to look up Jack Doyle. He had a 17-year career with a .299 batting average and 518 stolen bases compiled mostly during the 1890s as he bounced around 10 different teams.

Image result for max bishop baseball
Of course, the bat is on his shoulder

Max Bishop was a solid defensive second baseman who could walk as well as anyone – well, anyone who wasn’t named Ted Williams. He retired with a .423 lifetime on-base percentage.

Image result for mike hargrove baseball

One of my favorite players was Mike Hargrove. He was the original “human rain delay” but boy could he hit! He could take a walk, too, garnering a .396 lifetime on-base percentage.

Image result for bob watson baseball millionth
Loved those old Astros uniforms

I included Bob Watson in the tournament because he scored Major League Baseball’s one-millionth run in 1975. I was eleven years old and this was thrilling for me to experience the buildup toward that magic number. I remember watching the Indians game and someone being stranded on third base who could have had the honor. Rod Carew almost made it but was thrown out at home plate.

The Results

Paul Molitor9757.630*WON*
Roberto Alomar8569.55212.0
Johnny Bench8470.54513.0
Mike Hargrove7480.48123.0
Nellie Fox7282.46825.0
Jack Doyle7183.46126.0
Bob Watson7084.45527.0
Max Bishop6391.40934.0

Paul Molitor had a winning record every month of the season, parlaying that into a convincing victory over the rest of the league.

In notable performances: in one game, a Max Bishop struck out 6 times in his first 6 trips to the plate before drawing a walk and scoring in the 16th inning. On the season, there were 4 no-hitters, including one thrown by Tom Seaver on the 4th of July.

Molitor is joined by Roberto Alomar, Johnny Bench, Mike Hargrove, and Nellie Fox (positive run differential) in the third round. Doyle, Watson, and Bishop can try their luck in Round 2.

Tim Bruno

Tim has been a baseball fan for most of his life and has played a great deal of baseball and softball over the years. Although his playing days are long behind him, he remembers back when he was an extremely fast catcher with an extremely bad arm. He has been playing Strat-o-Matic baseball since he was 14. Tim is currently living in southwest France and writes A LOT about coffee at He has also written Procaffeination: A Coffee Lover's Dictionary, which will be available soon. You can find out more about Tim's writing at and if you want to contact him about the tournament, drop him an email at

Recent Posts

link to Round 4 S26

Round 4 S26

The Hitters We are treated to a true mix of players for this elimination round, covering a broad swath of baseball history. Top seed Herman Long hails from the 19th century with...